NTSB cites Uber, distracted backup driver in deadly self-driving crash


WASHINGTON (Information) – The U.S. Nationwide Transportation Security Board (NTSB) on Tuesday took Uber (UBER.N) to process for what it mentioned had been weaknesses in its strategy to security because it laid out its findings within the investigation of the first-ever loss of life involving a self-driving car, which additionally cited the car’s back-up security driver.

FILE PHOTO: Site visitors passes an intersection simply north of the situation the place a girl pedestrian was struck and killed by an Uber self-driving sport utility car in Tempe, Arizona, U.S., March 19, 2018. Information/Rick Scuteri/File Picture

It mentioned state and federal regulators must do extra to safeguard drivers on public roads.

The crash in March 2018 killed 49-year-old Elaine Herzberg as she was strolling a bicycle throughout a road at evening in Tempe, Arizona.

“The collision was the final hyperlink of an extended chain of actions and selections made by a corporation that sadly didn’t make security the highest precedence,” NTSB Chairman Robert Sumwalt mentioned. The board criticized a sequence of selections by Uber that it mentioned had been the results of “ineffective security tradition” on the time.

The NTSB voted Three-Zero that the possible reason for the Uber crash was the failure of the back-up security driver to observe the driving setting “as a result of she was visually distracted all through the journey by her private cellphone.”

Police have mentioned the crash was “fully avoidable” and that the operator was watching “The Voice” TV program on the time of the crash. Police haven’t determined if the driving force may face costs.

Nat Beuse, head of security for autonomous car efforts of the ride-sharing firm Uber, mentioned in an announcement that the corporate stays “dedicated to enhancing the security of our self-driving program” after making vital enhancements.

The NTSB cited as contributing components Uber’s insufficient security risk-assessment procedures and ineffective oversight of the backup driver.

The board additionally cited the pedestrian’s crossing exterior a crosswalk and the Arizona Division of Transportation’s inadequate oversight of autonomous car testing.

The NTSB urged the Nationwide Freeway Site visitors Security Administration (NHTSA) to require entities testing self-driving automobiles submit a security self-assessment report back to the company and for the company to find out if plans embody applicable safeguards and mentioned states ought to do extra to supervise the automobiles.

NHTSA mentioned would fastidiously overview the NTSB’s suggestions. It added in an announcement, “It’s essential for the general public to notice that each one automobiles on the highway immediately require a totally attentive operator always.”

The board mentioned solely a small quantity corporations truly submit the assessments and a few supply little helpful info.


Whereas Uber has made vital enhancements, Sumwalt will inform a U.S. Senate panel on Wednesday he has broader considerations about questions of safety within the self-driving car sector. “We stay involved concerning the security tradition of the quite a few different builders who’re conducting comparable testing,” Sumwalt’s testimony seen by Information mentioned.

The NTSB’s suggestions will doubtless reverberate throughout the business. The Arizona crash was the first-ever loss of life attributed to an autonomous car and prompted vital security considerations in regards to the nascent self-driving automotive business, which is working to get automobiles into business use.

The NTSB beforehand disclosed that the Uber car had vital software program flaws, noting the software program did not correctly determine Herzberg as a pedestrian and didn’t embody a consideration for jaywalking pedestrians. Herzberg was not crossing at an intersection. Uber had additionally deactivated a Volvo computerized emergency braking system within the XC90 check car it had modified.

The NTSB mentioned on Tuesday it deliberate to determine the necessity for “security danger administration necessities for testing automated automobiles on public roads,” signaling a broader query about how superior automobiles are examined and U.S. authorities oversight.

Slideshow (2 Photos)

Within the aftermath of the crash, Uber suspended all testing of self-driving car. It resumed testing final December in Pennsylvania with revised software program and vital new restrictions and safeguards.

In March, prosecutors in Arizona mentioned Uber was not criminally liable within the self-driving crash. Police are nonetheless investigating whether or not the security driver who was behind the wheel and supposed to reply within the occasion of an emergency ought to face felony costs.

The NTSB mentioned Uber did not adequately monitor backup security drivers and lacked different vital security guidelines.

Reporting by David Shepardson; enhancing by Leslie Adler